
Starbucks has removed the Impossible Breakfast Sandwich from its U.S. menu, ending a partnership with Impossible Foods that began in 2020. This decision leaves Starbucks without any plant-based meat options nationwide.
The sandwich, featuring an Impossible Sausage patty, egg, and cheddar on ciabatta, was Starbucks’ first nationally launched breakfast item made with plant-based meat. Its removal follows a similar move by White Castle, which replaced its Impossible Slider with a Dr. Praeger’s veggie patty in 2025.
Experts Weigh In on the Removal
Nikki Arctic, founder of The Future of Cool and author of Go Vegan, suggests that while one restaurant dropping a product shouldn’t be overstated, it raises questions about how well the offering served customers. Arctic notes that the sandwich, while containing plant-based meat, wasn’t a vegan meal.
“Impossible’s opportunity is to help partners build complete meals that appeal to vegans while also winning over people who ordinarily order meat,” Arctic said.
Mario Vivas, founder of Criollas Baked Empanadas, views the removal as a sign that the plant-based category has moved past its novelty phase. He said that losing a national breakfast slot often indicates that repeat orders didn’t justify the price and taste compared to traditional options.
“I don’t think it ends Impossible, but it shrinks the business to the places where the product genuinely wins, and it puts pressure on every menu slot it still holds,” Vivas added.
Impossible Foods’ Path Forward
Vivas stresses that Impossible Foods must compete on the plate, not just on its mission. “Get the price closer to the meat equivalent, make the cooked product taste like food people crave rather than a substitute they accept, and work with operators on formats that hold up in real service,” he said.
Expert Advice for Plant-Based Success
Arctic recommends offering fully plant-based meals as the default, avoiding the need for customers to make substitutions. This approach should focus on creating craveable food that is easy to order, with animal welfare and sustainability as additional benefits.