Cal-Maine agreed to pay a $1.5 million civil penalty and donate 30 million eggs as part of a settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice and a coalition of states accusing three major egg producers of colluding to fix prices.
Details of the settlement and its scope
The agreement follows a DOJ investigation into whether the firms exchanged bidding information to manipulate an industry price index that determines what grocery stores, restaurants and other buyers pay for eggs. The alleged conduct spanned from June 2022 through March 2025, a period when egg prices surged to record levels for consumers.
Cal‑Maine will distribute the donated eggs to nonprofits and food banks across the 17 states that participated in the settlement, which include Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Hawaii, Iowa, Maryland, Minnesota, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Texas, Utah, Vermont, and Wisconsin.
Alongside Cal‑Maine, Hickman’s Egg Ranch and Versova reached settlements that together total $3.3 million. The three firms have also agreed to appoint new antitrust compliance officers and adopt additional compliance measures.
Related: Hormel to sell Brazil operations
Company statements and the broader regulatory context
Cal‑Maine said the settlement does not constitute an admission of guilt. In a statement, the company described the period under review as “a particularly challenging time” for its operations, citing “temporary supply shocks” such as avian influenza outbreaks, the COVID‑19 pandemic, weather events and high inflation as drivers of price spikes.
President and CEO Sherman Miller added, “As farmers, we face extreme variability across supply and demand in markets that are often unpredictable.” He noted that the firm left the cooperative in May 2024, before the DOJ opened its investigation.
Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward, speaking for the Justice Department, said, “No product more representative of affordability than the price Americans pay for eggs. These actions prove this Department’s continued commitment to protecting competition and providing real relief for everyday Americans’ pocketbooks.”
Regulators have been scrutinizing price‑setting behavior in several food sectors. The Justice Department also opened an antitrust probe into beef producers in May, saying it is exploring “every law enforcement tool available to help reduce food prices.” At the same time, industry groups argue that recent price increases stem from factors beyond their control, such as a severe bird‑flu outbreak that decimated chicken flocks and drought conditions that have reduced cattle supplies.
While the settlement addresses alleged collusion, the firms maintain that their bidding communications “did not impact egg prices in any market.” The DOJ’s case rests on the premise that coordinated bid inflation artificially raised the industry index, which in turn lifted the prices paid by retailers and ultimately consumers.
Related: Nestlé boosts automation at new distribution center
Future compliance commitments could shape how egg producers interact with each other. If the new antitrust officers enforce stricter monitoring, firms may become more cautious about sharing market data, potentially reducing the risk of coordinated pricing.
However, the underlying volatility in agricultural supply chains—driven by disease, weather and global demand—means price pressures could reappear even without overt collusion.
Cal‑Maine’s financial performance reflects the market shift. The company reported a 53 % decline in net sales for the first quarter of 2026 as egg prices receded from their peak.
The donation of 30 million eggs is expected to benefit food‑insecure households across the settlement states, though the exact number of recipients has not been disclosed.